I am in agreement that perhaps the policy itself may need to be reviewed, but until it is and until they change it, that's just the way it is right now. Just like I didn't agree with going into Iraq but it would be wrong to leave early. Once you're in a situation, you deal with it. If this is how the policy is set up now, you deal with it until voters organize and change the law the legal route. I agree, soldiers are trained to kill, not to apprehend. That's why it's called 'war'... the 'drug war'. In war people get killed. I would call this an unfortunate incident. The goat herder didn't know what he was shooting at and the soldiers didn't either. Why can he shoot, but they can't?! No one has answered that question...