User login
Navigation
Reporters' Notebooks
- Kristin Bricker
- Brenda Norrell
- Allan Brauer
- Okke Ornstein
- Bill Conroy
- Miguel Contreras
- Charlie Hardy
- Marc Van Riper
- RJ Maccani
- John Viescas
- Christopher Fee
- Gregory Berger
- Katie Halper
- Jessica Davies
- Don Henry Ford Jr.
- Benjamin Melançon
- John Slade
- Dennes Longoria
- Diana Barahona
- Romina Trincheri
- Erich Moncada
- Jay J. Johnson-Castro Sr.
- Narco News
- Al Giordano
- Mark Smith
- Daniel Fleming
- Nick Cooper
- Dan Feder
- Stephen Peacock
- Laura del Castillo
- Charles Mostoller
- Jeb Sprague
- David B. Briones
- Aaron Shuman
- Nancy Davies
- John Bruning
- Marcos Meconi
- Keith Yearman
- Jonathan Mills
- Cindy Lou Wilmore
- Sean Donahue
- Juan Trujillo
- Jeff Simpson
- Paul Henry
- George Salzman
- Christopher Whalen
- Simon Fitzgerald
- Wim Dankbaar
- Charles Faris
- Diego Mantilla
- Shawn O'Bryant
- Christopher Hyde
- David Keating
- Rich Gibson
- Anthony Fenton
- Steve Young
- Richard Pilkington
- Tatiana Ovando
- Jeremy Gordon
- Ricardo Sala
- Randall White
- Luis Gomez
- Teofilo Ballve
- Ben Masel
- Walt Lyford
- Jeremy Bigwood
- John F. Eden
- Irene Roca Ortiz
- Ron Smith
- Kevin Skerrett
- Jean Friedsky
- Gissel Gonzales
- María Eugenia Flores Castro
- José Mirtenbaum
- Manuela Aldabe
- Kevin Gallagher
- Bill Weaver
- Justin Delacour
- Claudia Espinoza
- Andrew Stelzer
- Reber Boult
- Colleen Glynn
- Mike DAllaire
- Jennifer Whitney
- Stan Gotlieb
- Alex Satanovsky
- Marcel Miranda
- Nate Johnson
- Richard Eramian
- Pablo Mamani
- Paul Silvester
- Franz J.T. Lee
- Chris Herz
- Andrei Tudor
- Nora Callahan
- Gurujiwan Khalsa
- Julia Steinberger
- Fabio Mesquita
- Yasmin Khan
- Pablo Francischelli
- Baylen Linnekin
- Erik Siegrist
- Natalia Viana
- Amber Howard
- Linda Langness
- Kevin Okabe
- Sarah de Haro


A Tale of Two (Kinds of) Movements
Submitted June 8, 2005 - 12:20 am by Al GiordanoYesterday I was trying to explain to our latest scholar this same sensation that you are feeling. It is, I think, the reason I stayed in Latin America after coming here years ago. My belly was full of the self-indulgence of white, middle class, political demonstrations and causes with lefty pretensions in the United States that, although they had worthy goals, became exercises in futility precisely because of the protagonist "look at ME" nature of them.
I found, first in the discipline and seriousness of the Zapatistas, and later in many other social movements (primarily indigenous movements) in Latin America that same sense of purpose and desire to WIN. And I felt more at home than I had in many, many years participating in the movements of my own country. I knew that these were the people I could trust in the same foxhole as me, and I had lost that feeling - through experience - in the United States, where political movements become basically excuses for feel-goodism, self-satisfaction and for acting out personal psychodramas on a public stage while placing a "political" gloss on it.
I no longer can suffer such fools. The other night I was asked to strum my guitar at a friend's going away party. After I performed, an attractive youngster came up and started talking to me, said she was part of an "NGO" that worked to save the environment. I replied that there is a water park planned for a place near here and the neighbors are organized to stop it and they could sure use the help of her NGO. She replied, "Oh no, we don't believe in being controversial or fighting against things. We just want to promote the positive and sacred."
So I mentioned the story of another town, and its battle, by the indigenous population, against a golf club, and how a famous hippie commune in that town shrunk from its duty to join in the defense of the town. I mentioned that these hippies went around claiming to be following "indigenous ways" but when push came to shove and the indigenous neighbors needed their money and their connections, they turned into "culeros" (roughly translated: "cowardly assholes.") She said, "oh I was part of that commune back then, and it's not true that we didn't participate."
"Oh, really?" I said. "What did you do?"
"We held drum circles and prayed to the Earth Mother."
I stood up, disgusted with this kind of indulgent form of "activism," said, "best of luck to you" with a sneer and walked away. I just have no time for such people anymore.
So, welcome aboard, Jean, with extra enthusiasm. You're a great reporter, a brilliant writer, and you've let me relive some of my early days in Latin America by reading your reports in recent days. Welcome to the team. Stick around. We need a lot more like you!