User login
Navigation
Reporters' Notebooks
- Kristin Bricker
- Brenda Norrell
- Allan Brauer
- Okke Ornstein
- Bill Conroy
- Miguel Contreras
- Charlie Hardy
- Marc Van Riper
- RJ Maccani
- John Viescas
- Christopher Fee
- Gregory Berger
- Katie Halper
- Jessica Davies
- Don Henry Ford Jr.
- Benjamin Melançon
- John Slade
- Dennes Longoria
- Diana Barahona
- Romina Trincheri
- Erich Moncada
- Jay J. Johnson-Castro Sr.
- Narco News
- Al Giordano
- Mark Smith
- Daniel Fleming
- Nick Cooper
- Dan Feder
- Stephen Peacock
- Laura del Castillo
- Charles Mostoller
- Jeb Sprague
- David B. Briones
- Aaron Shuman
- Nancy Davies
- John Bruning
- Marcos Meconi
- Keith Yearman
- Jonathan Mills
- Cindy Lou Wilmore
- Sean Donahue
- Juan Trujillo
- Jeff Simpson
- Paul Henry
- George Salzman
- Christopher Whalen
- Simon Fitzgerald
- Wim Dankbaar
- Charles Faris
- Diego Mantilla
- Shawn O'Bryant
- Christopher Hyde
- David Keating
- Rich Gibson
- Anthony Fenton
- Steve Young
- Richard Pilkington
- Tatiana Ovando
- Jeremy Gordon
- Ricardo Sala
- Randall White
- Luis Gomez
- Teofilo Ballve
- Ben Masel
- Walt Lyford
- Jeremy Bigwood
- John F. Eden
- Irene Roca Ortiz
- Ron Smith
- Kevin Skerrett
- Jean Friedsky
- Gissel Gonzales
- María Eugenia Flores Castro
- José Mirtenbaum
- Manuela Aldabe
- Kevin Gallagher
- Bill Weaver
- Justin Delacour
- Claudia Espinoza
- Andrew Stelzer
- Reber Boult
- Colleen Glynn
- Mike DAllaire
- Jennifer Whitney
- Stan Gotlieb
- Alex Satanovsky
- Marcel Miranda
- Nate Johnson
- Richard Eramian
- Pablo Mamani
- Paul Silvester
- Franz J.T. Lee
- Chris Herz
- Andrei Tudor
- Nora Callahan
- Gurujiwan Khalsa
- Julia Steinberger
- Fabio Mesquita
- Yasmin Khan
- Pablo Francischelli
- Baylen Linnekin
- Erik Siegrist
- Natalia Viana
- Amber Howard
- Linda Langness
- Kevin Okabe
- Sarah de Haro


Thou Shalt Not Steal
Submitted March 17, 2004 - 10:29 am by Al GiordanoAnd Moses said, "well, I got it down to ten but he still wants adultery in there."
But, ah, I digress...
One of our copublishers here, Charles Faris, participates in a very interesting group blog called the Charles Baudelaire blog. Some weeks back he published a very revealing set of emails regarding the libel against Brazilian drug policy reform leader Fabio Mesquita.
It was, in fact, the need to correct all the disinformation spread in those days by some U.S. activists that led me to ask Karine Mueller to write the excellent story published today on Narco News with the true facts about Brazil's New Drug Law.
Anyway, Charles has just succeeded in shining even more sunlight on the libeling organization, DRCNet of Washington, DC, which, when it so often gets a story about Latin America wrong, doesn't offer honest corrections, and when it sometimes gets a story right, as revealed this week on Charles' blog, it steals the translations and doesn't credit we proles in the working class that did all the heavy lifting to bring those stories to the English-speaking world.
Charles caught them in the act of ripping off not one, not two, but three Narco News translations last week, without crediting the source.
(That's pretty hilarious on a number of counts, especially since David Borden, the imploding director of that organization, wrote to Faris, weeks ago, "I urge you not to rely on Narco News for accurate news reporting or for rational perspectives on other organizations or activists." Meanwhile, Borden obviously doesn't even believe his own bullshit because just last week, he stole three of our reports and original translations without crediting us.
Apparently, our reports are, indeed, credible and coveted enough to be plagiarized even as Dave Borden and Phil Smith flail around doing their best Gerard Latortue imitations when caught in yet another act of illegitimacy, dishonesty, and violation of the most basic journalistic ethics: the need to credit the source.
There's a reason they don't credit sources (I'm hardly the only victim of this: they do it to everyone.) They want their readers to have a false impression that they do the work, so they can then ask the readers to pay their salaries. It is theft, followed by deceit about that theft, pure and simple. It is most of what they do.
Perhaps the most interesting part of Borden's most recent email implosions, published on Charles' blog, is the seething paranoia he displays in response to Charles' very polite questions (I must say, Charles is very talented at getting folks to reveal their essential characters by playing it fair and straight himself):
In fact, I didn't attack them publicly for it. The matter has never been mentioned before now on Narco News, nor on The Narcosphere, nor on my BigLeftOutside blog. But that passage above offers an interesting glimpse into the mentality of these serial plagiarists.
In fact, last year I did write to Borden and Smith about previous thefts of our translations and work (about half of what they ever publish on Latin America, and the only times they get the story right, comes when they steal from Narco News). They didn't issue any correction then either. In fact, Borden, a year ago, right after I asked for a financial accounting of $88,000 supposedly spent by his organization on last year's drug legalization summit in Merida (of which, as a member of the steering committee for that event, I can't find an accounting for $30,000 dollars of it, or any evidence that it was spent on the conference), threw a tantrum that included a demand that I never contact him again and a claim that he had blocked all my email addresses from his mailbox.
Now he's telling Faris that I should have written him? If he's blocked emails from me, how would he know if I have or have not? In any case, his paranoid raving that "Al Giordano publicly attacks us for it, does not write us about it, and the first we hear about his complaint is from you," is pure fantasy. This is only the third time I've offered a critique of his unethical activity in public, only the second time on Narco News (the last time was to defend the good name of Fabio Mesquita from the Borden-Smith libel squad), and it comes after, not before, his frothing at the mouth hallucination that, if some reader somewhere also notices his plagiarism, that therefore Big Bad Al must have "publicly attacked" him over it.
Well, I didn't. But now that yet another false claim by these Beltway Bandits is published on the Internet, and they can't seem to grasp the essence of the matter, I'll simply quote that early drug policy reformer from Mount Sinai, who had a newsletter carved in stone: "Thou Shalt Not Steal."
Instead of flailing around with paranoid fantasies, they should do what ethical people do: Issue a correction, learn from their mistakes, and move on.