The "No Drama" Policy in Action: Richardson Withdraws as Commerce Secretary

By Al Giordano

New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson today withdrew his name from nomination for US Commerce Secretary:

A federal grand jury is investigating how a California company that contributed to Richardson's political activities won a lucrative New Mexico state contract...

A person familiar with the proceedings has told The Associated Press that the grand jury is looking into possible "pay-to-play" dealings between CDR Financial Products and someone in a position to push the contract through with the state of New Mexico.

The Washington Post reported on grand jury activity surrounding the New Mexico contract on December 16:

In the New Mexico case, the FBI and federal prosecutors are investigating how CDR, based in Beverly Hills, Calif., won lucrative fees from the New Mexico Finance Authority in 2004 soon after donating $100,000 to two Richardson organizations.

From 2003 to 2004, CDR Financial gave $75,000 to Sí Se Puede, which paid for expenses at the Democratic National Convention in 2004. CDR's president and founder, David Rubin, also gave $25,000 to Moving America Forward, which funded Richardson's efforts to register Hispanic and American Indian voters.

Two weeks later, Richardson bows out.

Here's the official statement:

STATEMENT OF PRESIDENT ELECT BARACK OBAMA

It is with deep regret that I accept Governor Bill Richardson's decision to withdraw his name for nomination as the next Secretary of Commerce. Governor Richardson is an outstanding public servant and would have brought to the job of Commerce Secretary and our economic team great insights accumulated through an extraordinary career in federal and state office. It is a measure of his willingness to put the nation first that he has removed himself as a candidate for the Cabinet in order to avoid any delay in filling this important economic post at this critical time. Although we must move quickly to fill the void left by Governor Richardson's decision, I look forward to his future service to our country and in my administration.

STATEMENT OF GOVERNOR BILL RICHARDSON

For nearly three decades, I have been honored to serve my state and our nation in Congress, at the U.N., as Secretary of Energy and as governor.  So when the President-elect asked me to serve as Secretary of Commerce, I felt a duty to answer the call.I felt that duty particularly because America is facing such extraordinary economic challenges.  The Department of Commerce must play an important role in solving them by helping to grow the new jobs and businesses America so badly needs.

It is also because of that sense of urgency about the work of the Commerce Department that I have asked the President-elect not to move forward with my nomination at this time.I do so with great sorrow.  But a pending investigation of a company that has done business with New Mexico state government promises to extend for several weeks or, perhaps, even months.

Let me say unequivocally that I and my Administration have acted properly in all matters and that this investigation will bear out that fact. But I have concluded that the ongoing investigation also would have forced an untenable delay in the confirmation process. Given the gravity of the economic situation the nation is facing, I could not in good conscience ask the President-elect and his Administration to delay for one day the important work that needs to be done.

So, for now, I will remain in the job I love, Governor of New Mexico, and will continue to work every day, with Lieutenant Governor Diane Denish, to make a positive difference in the lives of New Mexicans.  I believe she will be a terrific governor in the future. I appreciate the confidence President-elect Obama has shown in me, and value our friendship and working partnership.  I told him that I am eager to serve in the future in any way he deems useful.  And like all Americans, I pray for his success and the success of our beloved country.

New Mexico Lieutenant Governor Diane Denish - whose rise to the state's top job is now cut off at the pass - is probably more upset about this development than anybody else.

Obama's key words - "I look forward to his future service to our country and in my administration" - indicate that he doesn't think Richardson's problems will be permanent or long term.

This is how the "no drama" approach to government works. No individual is owed a particular post. And if - even through no fault of his or her own - that person might become a distraction, it's time to step aside until such a time as matters no longer distract.

Now, here's where this latest development gets interesting...

Somewhere in a country called Albany, in a state called New York, Governor David Paterson is reading the newspaper and thinking that if a questionable $100,000 in contributions can derail a cabinet nomination, he sure made the right call in waiting for a bona fide US Senate vacancy before naming his pick.

The New York Times reported yesterday:

An upstate New York developer donated $100,000 to former President Bill Clinton's foundation in November 2004, around the same time that Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton helped secure millions of dollars in federal assistance for the businessman's mall project.

Mrs. Clinton helped enact legislation allowing the developer, Robert J. Congel, to use tax-exempt bonds to help finance the construction of the Destiny USA entertainment and shopping complex, an expansion of the Carousel Center in Syracuse.

Mrs. Clinton also helped secure a provision in a highway bill that set aside $5 million for Destiny USA roadway construction.

It remains to be seen if one hundred-thousand dollar mini-scandal will gain as much traction as another, and whether Richardson's withdrawal might open the exit door for others.

Finally, I opine that US Rep. Xavier Becerra - who reportedly turned down Obama's offer to be US Trade Representative (Becerra's position in House leadership is arguably a more powerful position than trade rep) - could excel at the job of Commerce Secretary.

Never a dull moment, so far, in 2009!

Update: Meanwhile, it's beginning to look a lot like governance. This just in from the Obama transition:

President-elect Barack Obama will meet with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid on Capitol Hill on Monday.  Vice President-elect Joe Biden will join Obama for a meeting with Democratic and Republican congressional leadership on Capitol Hill on Monday afternoon.  Meeting participants will include Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, Senate Assistant Majority Leader Dick Durbin, Senate Minority Whip Jon Kyl, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer, House Minority Leader John Boehner, House Majority Whip Jim Clyburn and House Minority Whip Eric Cantor. There will be a pooled spray at the top of the bi-partisan meeting.

President-elect Barack Obama will hold a meeting with his top economic advisors on Monday afternoon at his Washington DC transition office.   There will be a pooled spray at the end of the meeting.  Participants in the meeting will include Melody Barnes, Director-designate, Domestic Policy Council; Carol Browner, Assistant-designate to the President for Energy and Climate Change; Former Senator Tom Daschle, Health and Human Services Secretary-designate and Director-designate, White House Office on Health Reform;  Rahm Emanuel, Chief of Staff-designate; Timothy Geithner, Treasury Secretary-designate; Ron Klain, Chief of Staff-designate, Vice President-elect; Peter Orszag, Director-designate, Office of Management and Budget; Christina Romer, Director-designate, Council of Economic Advisors and Lawrence Summers, Director-designate, National Economic Council. 

Sixteen days and counting...

 

Comments

As far as Lt. Gov. Denish is concerned

I wouldn't be too worried about her political future, she's still almost certain to be the Democratic nominee for governor in 2010 (I can only see one Democrat seriously challenge her, Albuquerque mayor Martin Chavez who would do it out of sheer chutzpah), though it complicates the general election campaign (word is that Heather Wilson the (as of this week) former Representative of NM-01 [the Albuquerque area] wants to run, and she'd be formidable).

It's too bad though, I like Richardson, he would've done a good job in Commerce, but this is something that would needlessly complicate Obama's administration, and kudos to President-Elect Obama for keeping open the door for Gov. Richardson's to possibly serve in the administration later on.

"The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie, deliberate, contrived and dishonest, but the myth, persistent, persuasive and unrealistic.” JFK

Highly unlikely...

It's highly unlikely that the Congel donation to Bill Clinton's library, after Hillary Clinton arranged financing for an upstate New York project in which the donor was involved, will derail her nomination as Secretary of State.  There's no simple equivalence between that and the case prompting Bill Richardson's withdrawal as nominee for Secretary of Commerce, for two reasons.  First, it's a more serious matter when a state's chief executive by himself makes a decision that directly benefits a donor, than when a single legislator pushes a bill that's also voted on by another 99 legislators.  If the policy benefit had to be judged by an entire legislative body, that makes it difficult to prove that personal corruption was the reason for the action.  Second, the alleged personal benefit went to her husband's foundation and not to her, and if this statement cannot be disproved -- "Mrs. Clinton did not solicit the donation from Mr. Congel or discuss it with him or anyone on his behalf, and...she was unaware of its timing and size until last month" -- then the allegation is unprovable.  Bill Clinton's shameless corraling of donors who wanted to cozy up to a former president will eventually lead to legislation mandating disclosure of donors to presidential libraries that receive official papers or any federal support.  But knowing of the increasingly separate official lives of these two spouses, there aren't many members of the Senate who are going to rake her over the coals for this.  A few questions?  Yes, but it won't be a Secretary of State deal-breaker...

What about Congressional "No Drama"

I feel pretty great about how Obama has handled these kinds of brush fires, whether we're talking during the campaign or during the transition.

IMO, the biggest threat to the administration and the Left's credibility will be the failure of the Dem's Congressional leadership to apply  the same kind of accountability in the House and Senate.

Reid's threat to keep Burris out of the Senate with armed security indicates that he clearly hasn't gotten the memo re: drama.

And what will House Dems if investigations into Charlie Rangel continue to yield unhelpful headlines?

Curious as to your thoughts on Obama's role vis-a-vis the Party and Congress...

Plenty of Drama for Arizona

Drama or no-drama, I think it would be a real mistake to seat Burris. Would open that seat up to potential loss in 2010.

Here's hoping for a mini-scandal that might keep Governor Nepalitano at home for a couple more years. The one question I have about the transition is why they would select a governor who will be replaced by a Republican, particularly in a potential future swing state. For those of us in Arizona who care about the quality of our public schools and universities, hospitals and other services, this is a huge problem. Her successor, Republican Secretary of State Jan Brewer, will go along with a radical state legislative agenda that will slash and burn our budget rather than subject the rich to tax increases despite huge tax cuts over the last ten or so years.

Virginia Gov. Tim Kaine to head DNC

Virginia Gov. Tim Kaine has been chosen by President-elect Barack Obama to head the Democratic National Committee, a Democratic official said.

The pick is a bet that an energetic younger leader will help the party capitalize on the historic enthusiasm that swept Obama to his landslide win.

Kaine, like Obama a graduate of Harvard Law School, was among the earliest statewide officials to endorse Obama, and was among finalists to be the vice presidential candidate on his ticket.

Kaine has long one of the party's rising younger stars, even delivering his party's nationally televised response to one of President George W. Bush's State of the Union addresses.

The governor won handily in a traditionally Republican state in part with frank conversation about his Roman Catholic faith. His victory in the state's exurbs is viewed as a model for other Democrats.

http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0109/17034.html

In other job news

...it's being reported that our old friend Gov. Tim Kaine is Obama's choice to head the DNC - interesting, yes???

No drama Giordano

One reason I return to your site is your own no-drama take on whatever political development is taking place. You can always count on Al to give a sober and reasoned response. No skies are falling, no cries about the lack of vetting, no ckickens scurrying about without heads.

Drama can be addictive and I am certainly not immune to its charms.  But ultimately, I rely on writers like youself to provide a calm center of rationality. No wonder Al appreciates Obama, they are kindred spirits.

WTF is a "pooled spray"?

Please, somebody help me out here.  What is a "pooled spray," and why does one have one at the "top" or the "end" of a meeting?

Pool Spray

Dr B.- Sorry not to explain that piece of press jargon. A pool reporter is one chosen by lottery to take photos and/or video and/or notes at an event that not all reporters are allowed to attend. His or her work is then available to all reporters.

A "spray" is a (usually brief) photo/video opportunity.

Thus, a "pooled spray," in this case, means that a photographer and a video camera and maybe a reporter will be allowed into those meetings for a few minutes to snap some photos and videos and maybe pen a few words, then will be escorted out. At that point the meetings begin for real, while the pool reporters make their work available to all.

Welcome to D.C.

I hope everyone caught PE Obama's arrival to D.C.  It was stirring!  And I just love your take on things, Al.  I read you all the time.

@ Al

I had wondered what that meant! I was hoping it meant that there would be a water fight where the politicians and reporters were in a swimming pool but alas the truth is more boring than that. ;-)

IMHO, our country would be better off if our nation's leaders resolved their problems with water fights more often.

Post new comment

Our Policy on Comment Submissions: Co-publishers of Narco News (which includes The Narcosphere and The Field) may post comments without moderation. All co-publishers comment under their real name, have contributed resources or volunteer labor to this project, have filled out this application and agreed to some simple guidelines about commenting.

Narco News has recently opened its comments section for submissions to moderated comments (that’s this box, here) by everybody else. More than 95 percent of all submitted comments are typically approved, because they are on-topic, coherent, don’t spread false claims or rumors, don’t gratuitously insult other commenters, and don’t engage in commerce, spam or otherwise hijack the thread. Narco News reserves the right to reject any comment for any reason, so, especially if you choose to comment anonymously, the burden is on you to make your comment interesting and relevant. That said, as you can see, hundreds of comments are approved each week here. Good luck in your comment submission!

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Support The Field

For site issues and problems logging in contact the tech team

User login

Meet the Field Hands

Meet the Field Hands in your area…

Field Hands Locals:

New chapters already forming in: North Colorado, Orange County CA, South Dakota, Cheshire County NH, Indiana, Georgia, Arizona, South Jersey NJ, Metro Motown MI, Northern New England, Texas, Iowa, Mississippi, Maryland, Smithtown/Commack NY, New Mexico, Louisville KY, Hampton Roads VA, Alabama, Philadelphia Metro PA, Oklahoma…

Don’t see a group in your region? Start one here.

RSS Feed